Christian Living & Ethics Theological Blindspot • BAS 67.4 4 Traditions Compared

Church, State, Sword & Christian Pacifism

Absolute Nonresistance vs. Just War & Magistracy in Matthew 5:38 & Romans 13:1–7

Examines Christ's command to 'resist not evil' and 'turn the other cheek' (Matt 5:38–44) in contrast to Paul's description of civil government bearing the sword to punish evildoers (Rom 13:1–7).

NT.MAT.5.38: “Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth:”
NT.ROM.13.1: “Let every soul be subject unto the higher powers. For there is no power but of God: the powers that be are ordained of God.”
NT.ACT.5.29: “Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men.”

Tradition Coverage & Representation Distribution

Calculated with epistemic tier weighting ($w \in [0.60, 1.00]$)
Anabaptist 25.4% Roman Catholic 25.4% Reformed/Presbyterian 25.4% Restorationist / Churches of Christ 23.9%

Historical Consensus & Common Ground

Universal confession that Christians are called to love their enemies, pray for persecutors, and respect civil authorities as established under God's providence.

The Crux of Divergence

Fundamental ethical divide between Christian nonresistance/pacifism (Anabaptist/Lipscomb CoC) and Just War theory with Christian participation in the state (Augustine/Luther/Calvin).

Theological Blindspot • BAS 67.4 High Asymmetry
Passage: NT.MAT.5.38, NT.ROM.13.1, NT.ACT.5.29

Heavily emphasized in Roman Catholic, Reformed/Presbyterian, with comparatively limited citation in other classical traditions.

High Emphasis:
Roman CatholicReformed/Presbyterian
Under-Represented:
AnabaptistRestorationist / Churches of Christ

Multi-Tradition Side-by-Side Framing Comparison

How each historical tradition interprets this passage, their core hermeneutic, key theologians, and primary citations.

Anabaptist

Absolute Christian Nonresistance and Separation of the Sword

Christocentric Discipleship (Sermon on the Mount)

The sword is ordained outside the perfection of Christ; Christians follow the nonresistant love of Jesus, refusing all participation in warfare, magistracy, civil violence, and judicial oaths.

menno-simons
  • Schleitheim Confession (1527), Article VI 'The Sword'
  • Menno Simons, The Cross of the Saints (1554)
Roman Catholic

Just War Tradition and Legitimate Defense

Natural Law and Common Good

Civil authorities possess legitimate moral authority to wage just defense against unjust aggression when all peaceful means have failed, following criteria formulated by Augustine and Aquinas.

augustine-of-hippothomas-aquinas
  • Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40 'Of War'
  • Augustine of Hippo, Letter 189 to Boniface
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, §2307–2317
Reformed/Presbyterian

Civil Magistrate as Minister of God for Justice

Covenantal Sphere Sovereignty

God has armed the civil magistrate with the power of the sword to defend the good and punish evildoers; Christians may lawfully accept the office of magistrate and wage just war.

john-calvin
  • Westminster Confession of Faith, ch. XXIII 'Of the Civil Magistrate'
  • John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, IV.xx
Restorationist / Churches of Christ

David Lipscomb's Non-Civil Kingdom Theology

Radical Two-Kingdom Restitution

All earthly human governments are of Satanic origin permitted by God to govern worldly men; the Christian's citizenship is solely in the kingdom of God, making political voting and military warfare incompatible with loyalty to Christ.

david-lipscombalexander-campbell
  • David Lipscomb, Civil Government: Its Origin, Mission, and Destiny (1889)
  • Alexander Campbell, Address on War (1848)

Connected Church History Lineages & Councils (65)

theologian 354–430 AD
Augustine of Hippo

Aurelius Augustinus was the monumental architect of Western Christian theology. In foundational works like *Confessions*, *On the Trinity* (De Trinitate), *The City of God* (De Civitate Dei), and anti-Pelagian treatises, he articulated the doctrines of original sin, sovereign irresistible grace, psychological Trinitarian analogies, and the distinction between the visible church and the elect invisible church.

council July 529 AD
Second Council of Orange (529 AD)

The Council of Orange was a provincial Western synod of fourteen bishops led by Caesarius of Arles that decisively affirmed Augustinian teaching on original sin and the absolute necessity of prevenient grace (gratia praeveniens) for any movement toward salvation, while rejecting fatalistic double predestination to damnation.

council 1438–1445 AD
Council of Florence (1438–1445 AD)

The Council of Florence was the 17th ecumenical council of the Catholic Church convoked by Pope Eugene IV, attended by Byzantine Emperor John VIII Palaiologos and Patriarch Joseph II of Constantinople, which proclaimed the reunion decree *Laetentur Caeli* (1439) resolving the Filioque, Purgatory, and papal primacy.

council 1545–1563 AD (Three Periods)
Council of Trent (1545–1563 AD)

The Council of Trent was the 19th ecumenical council of the Roman Catholic Church, representing the comprehensive dogmatic and disciplinary response of the Catholic Counter-Reformation to the Protestant Reformation. It defined the seven sacraments, the sacrificial nature of the Mass, the Latin Vulgate as authoritative, and condemned the Protestant doctrine of justification by faith alone (*sola fide*).

council November 1618 – May 1619 AD
Synod of Dort (1618–1619 AD)

The Synod of Dort was a national and international assembly of Reformed churches convoked by the Dutch States-General to resolve the Remonstrant controversy, rejecting the five articles of Jacobus Arminius and issuing the *Canons of Dort*, which codified the classic 'Five Points of Calvinism' (Total depravity, Unconditional election, Limited atonement, Irresistible grace, and Perseverance of the saints).

council July 1643 – February 1649 AD
Westminster Assembly of Divines (1643–1649 AD)

The Westminster Assembly was appointed by the Long Parliament to restructure the Church of England, producing the most influential confessional documents in English-speaking Presbyterian and Reformed history: the *Westminster Confession of Faith*, the *Larger Catechism*, the *Shorter Catechism*, and the *Directory for Public Worship*.

council December 1869 – October 1870 AD
First Vatican Council (1869–1870 AD)

The First Vatican Council was convoked by Pope Pius IX, issuing two landmark dogmatic constitutions: *Dei Filius* (defending Catholic faith against rationalism, pantheism, and materialism) and *Pastor Aeternus*, which solemnly defined that the Roman Pontiff possesses universal ordinary jurisdiction and speaks infallibly when teaching *ex cathedra* on faith and morals.

council October 1962 – December 1965 AD
Second Vatican Council (1962–1965 AD)

The Second Vatican Council was convoked by Pope John XXIII and concluded under Pope Paul VI, initiating an historic *aggiornamento* (bringing up to date) of the Roman Catholic Church. It produced sixteen documents including *Lumen Gentium* (on the church as the People of God), *Dei Verbum* (on divine revelation), *Sacrosanctum Concilium* (liturgical renewal in vernacular tongues), and *Dignitatis Humanae* (religious freedom).

Link copied to clipboard
Article Wiki

Title

Open Page → Explore