CONTROVERSY Apostolic & Patristic (30–451 AD) c. 410–529 AD Patristic (Apostolic)

Pelagianism & Semi-Pelagianism

Controversy over original sin, autonomous free will, and the necessity of grace

Pelagius, a British ascetic monk, taught that Adam's sin injured only himself and set a bad example, that infants are born in Adam's pre-fall state of innocence, and that human free will possesses the natural capability to fulfill God's commandments without the inner supernatural aid of grace. Semi-Pelagianism (modified by Cassian) conceded original sin but maintained that the initial step of faith (initium fidei) originates from human free will.

Geographical Center: Rome, Carthage, Hippo Regius, Southern Gaul Historical Catalyst: Council of Carthage (418 AD) and Second Council of Orange (529 AD)

Historical Context & Significance

Augustine of Hippo waged a relentless theological campaign against Pelagius, prompting synodal condemnations at Carthage (418 AD) and the ecumenical Council of Ephesus (431 AD), with the final Western settlement reached at Orange (529 AD) upholding sovereign prevenient grace.

Genealogical Lineage & Splits

Root Origin

This movement or council is an early root foundation with no preceding parent split in the dataset.

Theological & Hermeneutical Coordinates

Soteriology Autonomy of Free Will vs. Absolute Necessity of Prevenient Grace
Hermeneutic Legal and Moralistic Exegesis vs. Pauline Grace Exegesis
Ecclesiology & Sacraments Baptism as Admittance into Kingdom vs. Remission of Original Guilt
Eschatology Reward for Meritorious Obedience vs. Gift of Unmerited Glory

Primary Scripture Proof-Texts

Key biblical passages central to this tradition's exegesis and historical debates.

Connected Theological Perspectives & Debates

Link copied to clipboard
Article Wiki

Title

Open Page → Explore